Casper and Bear are highly rated online mattress brands known for their approachable mattress options that range from budget-friendly to luxurious.

No matter if you’re a side sleeper or a back sleeper, or if you’re debating between a foam or a hybrid, both Casper and Bear have options to choose from.

To help you make the best choice for you, we broke down the features of the various mattresses offered by Casper and Bear.

Pricing guide

Both Casper and Bear offer mattresses at a range of price points, from budget to luxury.

We reviewed seven queen-size mattresses in the following price levels:

  • $ = under $1,000
  • $$ = $1,000–$2,000
  • $$$ = over $2,000

Casper Element Mattress

Casper Element Mattress
  • Price: $
  • Type: Foam
  • Height: 10 inches
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Good for: People with shoulder and neck pain and people on a budget

Casper’s Element Mattress is their most affordable, basic option. It’s a good entry-level mattress for those who may be transitioning from a traditional spring mattress.

The all-foam mattress is available in one level of firmness: medium.

The Element Mattress is designed with two layers of foam. The bottom layer is supposed to be a foundational base that prevents the feeling of sinking in (which is common with memory foam).

Casper designed the perforated top layer to be breathable and pressure-relieving, since it conforms to your body.

Most reviewers say this mattress strikes a balance between soft and firm, though some note that it leans on the firmer side.

Many reviewers also say they purchased the mattress for their children — who find it comfortable — because of the great value.

Buy the Casper Element Mattress online.

Casper Original Mattress

Casper Original Mattress
  • Price: $$
  • Type: Foam and hybrid
  • Height: 11 inches
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Good for: All sleeping positions

The Casper Original is the company’s most popular mattress, which is clear from the thousands of customer reviews on the company’s website. This mattress is both soft and supportive and comes in all-foam and hybrid options.

Similar in construction to the Element Mattress, the Original Mattress features a top layer and base layer.

There’s also an additional layer designed with three different support zones. This is intended to promote spinal alignment, which makes the mattress good for all sleeping positions.

The zone around the shoulders and neck area offers softer foam, allowing these body parts to gently sink in. The area around the hips, waist, and lower back is firmer and more supportive.

The hybrid version of this bed features the same top two layers, but the base layer has springs for more support and increased airflow. The hybrid mattress also offers more edge support with its firmer border.

Reviewers praise this mattress for its comfort and support, noting that it improved their sleep. Most reviewers say this mattress is on the medium-to-firm end — of course, firmness is subjective.

Some reviews say the off-gassing (new mattress smell) is strong but lasts only a couple of days.

Buy the Casper Original Mattress online.

Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress

  • Price: $$
  • Type: Hybrid
  • Height: 12 inches
  • Firmness: Plush
  • Good for: Side sleepers and people wanting a softer feel

Casper’s Nova Hybrid mattress is one of the brand’s newer models. With a price point that’s higher than the Element Mattress and Original Mattress, the Nova Hybrid falls into the luxury mattress category.

The company says this mattress has a plush feel — it’s the company’s only plush model — making it a good option for side sleepers. The soft top layer is supposed to feel pillow-like, and some reviews liken it to sleeping on a cloud.

The Nova Hybrid also features ergonomic support zones to promote spinal alignment, but this model takes it a step further and has seven zones, versus the Original’s three.

This mattress also has two layers of Casper’s breathable AirScape foam, which has a perforated design that’s meant to better circulate air.

The base layer features hundreds of springs to help enhance overall support, improve edge support, and aid airflow.

Most customer reviews of this mattress are positive, with reviewers saying they sleep comfortably.

While some reviewers feel this mattress is too soft, most praise the support of the mattress, saying that, even though it falls on the plush side of the firmness scale, it doesn’t create a “sinking in” feeling.

Buy the Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress online.

Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress

  • Price: $$$
  • Type: Hybrid
  • Height: 13 inches
  • Firmness: Adjustable
  • Good for: People with back pain and people with higher body weight

Casper’s most luxurious option, the Wave Hybrid mattress is also their most supportive model. It’s designed specifically for people who have back pain.

Similar to the Nova Hybrid, this mattress includes three layers of the company’s AirScape foam and several ergonomic zones.

However, the standout feature that provides the most support is the layer with gel pods. These gel pods provide extra support to the lower back and hips.

The Wave also features a base layer of hundreds of spring coils designed to provide additional support.

This mattress is highly rated for its support, especially when it comes to back pain. Many reviewers say the mattress lives up to its claim, and they report improvements in their sleep after purchasing this mattress.

Buy the Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress online.

Bear Mattress

  • Price: $
  • Type: Foam
  • Height: 10 inches
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Good for: Back sleepers and people with back pain

This mattress is Bear’s original and most popular foam model. The mattress is labelled as medium firm, but it definitely falls on the firmer side at a 7.1 on a 10-point scale. This makes it a good option for back sleepers and those with back pain.

All of Bear’s mattresses feature a Celliant cover. Celliant is a proprietary synthetic fiber made by a company called Hologenix. The purpose of Celliant fiber is to absorb body heat, convert it into far infrared radiation (FIR), and then reflect that FIR back at the body. It is purported to improve athletic performance through its infrared-emitting technology.

Although the brand highlights claims from Hologenix that Celliant is an FDA-designated medical device and is FDA approved, Celliant is not actually registered or approved by the FDA. Additionally, Hologenix has been sued for making misleading claims.

Below that top layer of the mattress, there’s a graphite-gel memory foam layer that the company says helps keep you cool by extracting body heat.

There’s also a responsive transition foam layer for pressure relief and a high density support layer.

Reviewers praise this mattress for its support, saying that it’s best for back sleepers. Most reviewers note this is a pretty firm mattress, but it still offers just enough cushioning to make it comfortable.

Some reviewers who have back pain say this mattress helped improve their sleep and that they wake up with significantly less pain.

Buy the Bear Mattress online.

Bear Pro

  • Price: $$
  • Type: Foam
  • Height: 12 inches
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Good for: People who sleep hot and side sleepers

The Bear Pro is another all-foam option from this company, but there are a few differences between this mattress and the original.

This model is slightly less firm at a 6.5 on a 10-point firmness scale, offering a little more bounce than the Bear Mattress. However, it’s still considered medium firm.

Another difference is the additional layer in this mattress. The Bear Pro features a copper-infused foam layer which is supposed to be more cooling than the original.

Bear also designed this mattress to be more contouring, thanks to its all-foam construction for a cradling feeling and more pressure relief.

Both back and side sleepers claim to sleep comfortably on this mattress. Most reviewers praise this bed for being not too soft and not too firm.

Many reviewers also love the comfortable pillows that come with the mattress.

However, some reviews note there isn’t as much edge support as they’d like.

Buy the Bear Pro Mattress online.

Bear Hybrid

  • Price: $$
  • Type: Hybrid
  • Height: 14 inches
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Good for: People who prefer a traditional feel, couples, and all sleeping positions

Bear’s most luxurious model is the Bear Hybrid. It’s great for those who want the best of both worlds: This option strikes a balance between traditional coils and memory foam with a five-layer construction.

This mattress is the plushest of Bear’s offerings, and is rated a 6 on a 10-point scale.

The top layer of this mattress features Celliant fiber like Bear’s other two mattresses. But the difference is that it’s hand quilted, offering a look and feel that’s similar to a luxury hotel bed.

Premium cooling gel foam and transition foam layers sit on top of individually wrapped coils. The coils also help to minimize motion transfer and help provide better edge support, making this mattress a good option for couples.

The base layer is a high density foam that’s made to be durable and long-lasting.

Most reviewers say this hybrid mattress is very supportive while still providing comfort. Many praise the cloud-like quilted top layer.

Couples especially rate this mattress highly for its ability to reduce motion transfer.

Buy the Bear Hybrid Mattress online.

A mattress is a big investment, which means there are many factors to take into account.

Not only is a mattress something that will be part of your bedroom for several years, but choosing the right mattress is essential to making sure your overall sleep quality is healthy and sustainable.

Below are a few categories to consider when choosing the right mattress for you.

Price point

Though Casper and Bear offer comparable mattresses at varying price points, Bear’s mattresses are overall more affordable.

If you’re looking to get the most value from your mattress, however, Casper may be the best option. Some of Casper’s mattresses have a higher price point, but each of them offer high quality construction that’s highly praised by customers for both comfort and support.

Casper also offers a basic budget-friendly option for under $600 which may be a good entry point.

Mattress type

Both Casper and Bear offer foam and hybrid mattresses.

When choosing a mattress, keep in mind that foam mattresses are usually softer. They contour to your body’s shape, making them a good choice for side sleepers and those with less weight.

Hybrid mattresses offer a combination of support systems, often a spring base and foam layers to add extra comfort. This combination of coils and foam usually provides a more supportive and distributed base.

Hybrid mattresses are best for all body types and most sleeping positions, depending on their firmness level. However, they are often more expensive than traditional spring mattresses and foam mattresses.

Firmness

Everyone has a personal preference when it comes to the firmness level of their mattress. However, most mattresses are rated on a 10-point scale and many fall into the medium-firm range, which is anywhere between 5 and 7.

If you sleep on your back and stomach, firm mattresses offer more support. If you’re a side sleeper, you may prefer a softer feel.

Casper and Bear are similar in terms of firmness, but Bear is considered slightly firmer based on customer reviews. The Bear Mattress is the firmest option of all mattresses reviewed from both brands, with a rating of 7.1.

Casper’s memory foam feel is soft, but doesn’t create a “sinking in” feeling and allows the mattress to feel more supportive than other memory foam mattresses.

Temperature regulation

If you sleep hot, you’ll want to keep a few factors in mind when choosing a mattress.

Foam is known to trap heat, which means that foam mattresses may not be the best choice for hot sleepers. If you want to sleep on a memory foam mattress, though, look for breathable materials and layers that promote air flow.

Both Casper and Bear have built-in cooling features in all of their mattresses, including foams infused with gel, copper, and graphite. These are all designed to draw heat out and circulate air.

Casper’s mattresses all feature a perforated foam layer which is supposed to increase breathability.

Casper

Casper offers free shipping anywhere in the contiguous United States and Canada, with additional fees for Hawaii and Alaska.

The company also offers in-home delivery and setup for an additional $149.

Orders typically ship within 2 business days and are delivered via UPS.

Bear

Bear offers free shipping to the contiguous United States. Mattress and bed base shipping to Alaska or Hawaii is an additional $100.

Once you place your order, the mattress usually ships in 2 to 7 business days and is delivered via FedEx.

Casper

Casper offers a 100-night, risk-free sleep trial. Returns are free and Casper offers full refunds if the mattress is returned during the trial period.

Mattresses also come with a 10-year limited warranty.

Bear

Bear also offers a 100-night sleep trial. Returns are free, but you have to have the mattress for at least 30 nights before initiating a return.

Bear’s mattresses also come with a 10-year limited warranty.

Casper

Casper’s foams are CertiPUR-US certified, meaning the mattresses are made without ozone-depleting products or chemicals.

Bear

Bear’s mattresses are also CertiPUR-US certified. Additionally, Bear’s Hybrid mattress is Greenguard Gold certified, meaning it meets the strictest air quality standards.

Casper

Casper has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). The company’s BBB customer rating averages 2.58 out of 5 stars, and the company has received 33 reviews, most of which cite issues with customer service and order delays.

Casper is currently involved in one pending class action lawsuit that accuses them of hiding profit losses from investors.

Casper hasn’t recently recalled any products.

Bear

Bear has an A rating from the BBB. However, the company is not accredited.

Bear hasn’t been involved in any lawsuits in recent years.

Bear hasn’t recently recalled any products.

Casper

Overall, customer reviews recognize that Casper lives up to its reputation as being one of the earliest players in the online mattress game.

Customers overwhelmingly praise the mattresses for helping to improve their sleep quality. Most reviews note how comfortable the mattresses are, especially the hybrid models, and how the quality is well worth the investment.

The customer reviews on Casper’s website don’t seem to note many issues with customer service, delivery, or returns.

Bear

Though Bear hasn’t received as many reviews as Casper, customers rate the mattresses highly.

Their athlete-inspired mattresses are praised by athletes and non-athletes alike. In particular, the Celliant material seems to contribute to many customer reviews about overall comfort and improved sleep quality.

Customers also note the firmer support has helped alleviate pain.

Additionally, customers appreciate that Bear mattresses are made in the United States.

Overall, both Casper and Bear offer high-quality mattresses at comparable prices. At the end of the day, the better mattress for you depends on price and sleeping position.

If you’re looking for a mid-range mattress, then Bear is a great option. If you’re willing to make a bigger investment, Casper may be worth the splurge.

Back sleepers may prefer Bear’s medium-firm options, while side sleepers may appreciate the slightly softer options Casper offers.

Both brands offer the same 100-night sleep trial and free returns. So it’s never been easier to try them out to determine which one is best for you.


Sam Lauron is a freelance lifestyle writer based in Austin, TX. When she’s not writing about wellness, creativity, or personal development, she spends her time reading, listening to true crime podcasts, and soaking up the sunny Austin weather with her partner and their dog. Connect with her on Instagram or Twitter, or by visiting her website.