We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.
- Best budget Stearns & Foster mattress: Estate Hurston Mattress
- Best Stearns & Foster mattress for back pain: Estate Rockwell Mattress
- Best moisture-wicking Stearns & Foster mattress: Lux Estate Cassatt Mattress
- Best Stearns & Foster mattress without a pillowtop: Lux Estate Hybrid Pollock Mattress
If you’re shopping for a mattress, Stearns & Foster offers many options to fit your needs. The luxury brand has been around since 1846 and has maintained its long-lasting, quality craftsmanship throughout the years.
However, it’s important to keep in mind that a mattresses aesthetic is only one aspect to consider when shopping for one. It’s also important to think about if the mattress offers the support you need (especially if you experience chronic pain) and if it’s compatible with your sleeping style.
To help you make your choice, we’re reviewing some of the most popular Stearns & Foster mattresses. Read on for pros, cons, and useful information about buying from this brand.
- Support. The thick profiles seen in each of the mattresses offer plenty of support and height.
- Luxury look. Hand-crafted and made up of luxury memory foam and velvet accents, these mattresses are aesthetically pleasing.
- Customization. Each style offers various options to customize the feel. You can also add a pillow top for extra cushioning.
- 10-year warranty. Stearns and Foster offers a 10-year warranty. The company will replace or repair your mattress if it has a defect during this period.
- Federal flammability requirements. Stearns & Foster’s parent company, Sealy, only sells products certified by the Federal Flammability Standard 16 CFR part 1633, and 16 CFR part 1632.
- Expensive. Stearns & Foster’s pricing is on the higher end of the market, which may deter customers on a tighter budget.
- May require deep-pocketed sheets. Stearns & Foster mattresses range from 13.5 to 16 inches thick, so you may need special sheets.
- May be too tall for some people. The height can also make it a little challenging to get in and out of bed if you have limited mobility.
- Limited availability online. Mattresses can’t be purchased off the Stearns & Foster website and instead have to be purchased in store or through other online retailers.
- May have warranty issues. Some customers report issues using the warranty that comes with these mattresses.
Compared to other brands, Stearns & Foster is fairly expensive.
However, they do offer some less expensive options. Their more basic Estate line keeps their prices under $2,000 for a queen. The other lines can go over $3,000.
Prices in this review are based on queen-size mattresses.
- $ = under $2,000
- $$ = $2,000–$3,000
- $$$ = over $3,000
Stearns & Foster Estate Hurston Mattress
- Price: $
- Type: Hybrid
- Height: 14 inches without pillow top or 14.5 inches with pillow top
As one of Stearns & Foster mattresses with a lower price point, the Estate Hurston is ideal for anyone looking for a luxury feel that falls in a tighter budget.
The mattress is made of memory foam and a coil system for extra support. You can choose a firm, cushion firm, or plush feel.
Or, if you want a pillow top to elevate your sleeping experience, you’ll have your choice between firm and plush. The pillow top will run you an extra $200–$400, depending on the mattress size.
Customers rave about this mattress and say it sleeps comfortably without needing a “break in” period. One couple details in their review how, although their weights are significantly different, they never feel each other’s movements.
Stearns & Foster Estate Rockwell Mattress
- Price: $$
- Type: Hybrid
- Height: 13.5–14.5 inches without pillow top or 15 inches with pillow top
The Estate Rockwell is an upgraded version of the Estate Hurston. It’s made with an exclusive memory foam designed by Tempur-Pedic.
The mattress can be purchased in five firmness options: firm, plush, ultra firm, firm pillow top, or plush pillow top.
Satisfied customers say the mattress improved their lower back pain and that they wake up without pain in the mornings. One reviewer with osteoarthritis says they experience less pain now that they sleep on this mattress.
Back sleepers might appreciate this style mattress thanks to the firm feel and lumbar support. Some reviewers who have had back surgery also vouch that the Estate Rockwell offers the support for their needs.
Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Cassatt Mattress
- Price: $$
- Type: Hybrid
- Height: 13.5–14.15 inches without pillow top or 15–16 inches with pillow top
The Lux Estate Cassatt is made up of memory foam and coils, along with a top layer of moisture-wicking fibers. The mattress also includes air vents along the sides to provide breathability.
This style lets you pick from firm, plush, or ultra firm — with or without a pillow top.
Most reviewers seem to love this mattress. One reviewer even says sleeping on this mattress helped almost eliminate his lower back pain, and that it is comfortable even as a stomach sleeper.
Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Hybrid Pollock Mattress
- Price: $$$
- Type: Hybrid
- Height: 15–16 inches
This hybrid mattress is made with high-quality memory foam and coils. Many reviewers say it’s comfortable and gives them the best night’s sleep they’ve had in years.
This line is the only one to not offer a pillow top option, which may deter customers who want a higher profile and personalized feel. Still, it’s offered in three firmness levels: cushion firm, plush, and ultra-plush.
One reviewer raves that this mattress is like sleeping on a cloud every night and multiple customers say the mattress is comfortable for side and stomach sleepers. Another couple that had back surgery claims the mattress was great for them post-surgery and allowed them to sleep through the night.
Stearns & Foster offers multiple firmness levels for each of their mattress models. This makes it easy to choose a firmness that’s right for your particular sleep needs. Most models come in at least three firmness levels, from firm to pillow top.
While a mattress might feel firmer or softer depending on your weight, some customers complain that the firm mattresses quickly lost their rigid feel.
Customers seem to agree that Stearns & Foster mattresses do a good job of stopping motion. That means you can sleep soundly, even if your partner moves around a lot.
Reviewers report that the mattress edges stay firm, while the rest of the bed conforms to the body. You shouldn’t have any trouble if you happen to roll over to the edge of the bed in the middle of the night.
Stearns & Foster mattresses all contain high quality materials, including supportive coils designed to relieve pressure and memory foam for added comfort. The beds are also surrounded by coils that provide edge support.
Aside from the fact that the mattresses are crafted by Certified Master Craftsmen, the company’s website doesn’t mention any additional certifications. However, the mattresses do meet Federal Flammability Standards.
Side sleepers often feel comfortable on medium-firm mattresses, but this also depends on personal preference. If you sleep on your side, a medium-firm mattress provides support without digging into areas, like your shoulders and hips.
Reviewers who sleep on their sides seem to like the Lux Estate Hybrid Pollock Mattress for its cloud-like yet supportive feel.
Back sleepers tend to prefer firmer mattresses. However, how firm or soft a mattress feels to you may depend on your body type and size, so keep that in mind.
Those who tried the Stearns & Foster Estate Hurston Mattress seem to appreciate the model’s body contouring qualities that may help maintain spinal alignment.
If resting on your tummy is your preferred way to nod off, consider a medium-firm mattress that evenly distributes your weight, like the Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Cassatt Mattress or Lux Estate Hybrid Pollock Mattress.
If you’re looking to buy a mattress in a box, you may be disappointed to discover that you can’t buy a mattress off the Stearns & Foster website. The brand only sells online at authorized retailers like:
You can also use the Stearns & Foster store finder to locate a retailer near you.
Some retailers will run sales at certain times of the year. If you’re interested in purchasing a Stearns & Foster mattress, you might want to time your purchase around a holiday to save some money. Otherwise, the mattresses can cost upwards of $5,000 depending on the size and line.
This luxury brand offers many options to fit the qualities you find vital for a good night’s rest. Those who are new to Stearns & Foster, or those want the most affordable option, may want to opt for the Estate Hurston or Estate Rockwell.
The Estate Hurston offers a classic feel at a lower cost, while the Estate Rockwell includes Tempur-Pedic foam for added comfort.
The middle-of-the-road options are the Lux Estate Cassatt and Lux Estate Hybrid Pollock. With each of these, you’ll get a velvet inset and extra embroidery that add to the luxurious look. While the Cassatt offers a pillow top option, the Pollock doesn’t.
If you’re looking to splurge, you might be content sleeping on the Reserve Hepburn, which has a luxury look and feel.
Stearns & Foster manufactures their mattresses at facilities across the United States. It’s owned by Tempur Sealy International, which has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.
Despite the positive rating, the retailer has received many complaints tied to warranty. Many customers claim the company never gave them assistance during the 10-year warranty window.
In 2011, a customer who purchased a Stearns & Foster mattress from an Ohio retailer sued Sealy. He says he was denied warranty coverage for his defective mattress because of a minor stain.
According to the warranty policy, Sealy only covers sagging or other body indentations.
According to the Stearns & Foster website and other retailer sites, most customers are satisfied with their mattress’s quality and durability. Negative reviews are tied to warranty issues through the manufacturer.
In some cases, customers say they could not get used to the firm feel, or they experienced sagging only a few years into owning the mattress.
Stearns & Foster’s warranty, as previously mentioned, has a controversial history. According to the website, the mattresses have a 10-year warranty and are covered for manufacturing defects in the mattress or foundation.
Damage to the mattress, such as burns, cuts, tears, liquid damage, or stains, is not covered by the warranty. The warranty also doesn’t cover floor models or sample mattresses.
In order for a warranty to be valid, the mattress must be purchased at an authorized retailer.
Some authorized Stearns & Foster retailers allow you to try the mattress in your home for a certain number of nights before deciding if you want to keep it. If you buy online, you may want to explore the retailer’s trial policy before making a purchase.
Do Stearns & Foster mattresses need to be flipped or rotated?
The brand recommends rotating your mattress regularly to prolong its life. Because these mattresses are one-sided, they can’t be flipped.
Do Stearns & Foster mattresses go on sale?
Yes. If there aren’t offers available on the Stearns & Foster website, you may be able to find a deal at a local retailer. You can find out about promotions on the latest offers page of the website.
Can you try Stearns & Foster mattresses in a store?
The mattresses are sold at brick-and-mortar retail locations. In other words, yes, you can try them out in person, provided you live close enough to a store with stock. Check out the handy store locator page on the website to find a Stearns & Foster retailer near you.
Stearns & Foster mattresses can be expensive, but customers seem to like them. While you can’t purchase them online directly on the Stearns & Foster website, you should be able to find them online at other retailers.
Make sure you’re clear on the terms and conditions of the warranty before buying in order to avoid any potential problems down the line. As with any big purchase, it’s important to compare offerings from a variety of mattress brands to make sure you’re getting the best quality at a fair price point.
Giselle Castro is a freelance writer who lives in New York. She’s been published in Shape, Fitness, Women’s Health, and Hip Latina, among other sites. She is an avid runner and ran the New York City Marathon in 2019. She is passionate about wellness and fitness, and hopes to influence others through her writing.