We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.
Many online mattress offerings seem similar at first glance. You might feel overwhelmed by the options, and we get it! It’s why we’ve created these comparison guides to help you shop for a new mattress.
This article will break down the differences (and similarities) between the Saatva and WinkBed mattresses. We’ll give you a quick rundown of the two companies and go deeper to compare their policies and reputations.
Here’s a quick comparison of The WinkBed and Saatva Classic:
|The WinkBed||Saatva Classic|
|Firmness||4 firmness levels||3 firmness levels (at 2 heights)|
|Certifications||OEKO-TEX Standard 100 and CertiPUR-US||CertiPUR-US|
|Manufacturing||Handmade to order in the U.S.; sustainable manufacturing commitment||Handmade in the U.S.; coils made from recycled steel|
|Trial period||120 nights||180 nights|
The WinkBed Mattress
- Height: 13.5 inches
- Firmness: Available in 4 firmness levels, including softer, luxury firm (medium), firmer, and plus
- Warranty info: Lifetime warranty
The WinkBed mattress features a pillow top and gel foam that’s intended for pressure relief and temperature regulation.
Reviewers with back pain report restful sleep with this model. However, some customers complain that the firmest option is a bit too rock-like.
Overall, the mattress gets high ratings from customers who say it delivers good pain relief and decent edge support. Customers add that they don’t notice when their partner gets in and out of bed, too.
Saatva Classic Mattress
- Height: 11.5 or 14.5 inches
- Firmness: 3 firmness options, including plush soft, luxury firm (medium), and firm
- Warranty info: 15-year warranty
Like The WinkBed, you can choose from a few different firmness levels when buying the Saatva Classic.
The hybrid construction with steel coils is designed to provide support, while a pillow top is intended to give some softness. Reviewers love the luxurious, cushioned feel of the Saatva.
However, many customers note that the mattress tends toward the firmer side — even the plush-soft version.
While there’s no specific mention of the mattress’s cooling abilities, reviewers comment that the mattress helped them avoid overheating.
Here’s how delivery differs between WinkBeds and Saatva. Regardless of where you’re getting your mattress from, expect delivery delays related to COVID-19.
WinkBeds offers free shipping via UPS. Shipping is free within the contiguous United States. It only includes delivery to your front door.
You’ll get free white-glove delivery within the contiguous United States when you buy a Saatva mattress. This includes setup and removal of your old mattress.
Here’s how the companies differ in terms of customer service policies.
The WinkBed comes with a 120-night trial. You’ll need to try out the mattress for a minimum of 30 days before WinkBeds will accept a return or exchange.
Once you return a mattress, you’re no longer eligible for the trial period on future mattress purchases. For exchanges, you’ll get 60 nights to try out the second model.
The mattress comes with a lifetime warranty that covers indentations of 1.5 inches or more. You can read the full details of the warranty here.
You get slightly more time to try out the Saatva with 180 nights. Return it during the trial period, and you’ll get most of your money back, save for a $99 transportation fee.
If you exchange the mattress, you can’t try it out for another 180 nights or get a refund.
The mattress also comes with a 15-year, non-prorated limited warranty. This includes replacements within the first 2 years, no questions asked.
Both the Saatva Classic and WinkBed contain mattress foams that are CertiPUR-US certified. This means they don’t contain any of the following:
- heavy metals like lead or mercury
- PBDE flame retardants
The WinkBed mattress also contains materials that are OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified. This means the mattress has been independently tested for harmful substances.
According to the mattress product page, the Saatva Classic has a seal of approval from the Congress of Chiropractic State Associations.
What do these certifications mean?
Generally, an independent, third party tests the mattresses for the health and safety of certain materials. These materials can affect indoor air quality, which is why they’re important factors to some people.
Both companies have relatively similar reputations. We couldn’t find any information about any recent lawsuits related to business practices.
The most significant difference is that Saatva is a slightly older company compared to WinkBeds, so it’s had more time to build up positive cred.
WinkBeds isn’t accredited by the Better Business Bureau but has a B rating. There are only two ratings for the mattress on Trustpilot, both positive.
Saatva is accredited by the Better Business Bureau and has an A+ rating. It also has top ratings on Trustpilot.
Both companies generally have favorable reviews from customers across the board. The mattresses score high points for both comfort and quality.
WinkBeds is only 6 years old, so there aren’t too many customer reviews that refer to durability. However, Saatva has been around for a little longer at 10 years, and seems to score high praise from customers about mattress durability.
Saatva and WinkBeds also get positive comments about their customer service. However, both companies have a few complaints logged on the Better Business Bureau website.
Some of the recent complaints about Saatva delivery issues may have to do with pandemic-related delays.
As for WinkBeds, the handful of complaints are mostly from people who received defective mattresses that they say left them with back pain.
The Saatva Classic and WinkBed mattresses are both popular models from companies with solid reputations. Both Saatva and WinkBeds make their mattresses in the United States. They’re also committed to using high-quality materials.
Both mattresses get top marks from customers and are available in multiple firmness options. Since they’re both hybrid mattresses, they offer plenty of support that lands on the firmer side, so they may not be ideal choices for people who prefer a softer bed.
Steph Coelho is a freelance writer with chronic migraine who has a particular interest in health and wellness. When she’s not click-clacking away on her keyboard, she’s probably nose-deep in a good book.