Nectar and Casper are two bed-in-a-box companies known for quality mattresses at a low cost. But how do you choose between two seemingly similar companies?

It’s all in the details. Understanding what each company is known for, including special features and customer service, will get you started.

Read on to learn about what types of mattresses each brand offers, price ranges, certifications, and more.

Nectar Casper
Mattress typesall foamfoam (Original) or hybrid (Nova and Wave)
Price range$$–$$$$$$–$$$$$
CertificationsCertiPUR-US certifiedCertiPUR-US certified
Known for“forever warranty,” being comfortable for all sleeping stylesone of the first bed-in-a-box companies, being comfortable for all sleeping styles

Nectar mattresses

Nectar Memory Foam Mattress

Nectar Memory Foam Mattress
  • Price range: $$–$$$
  • Height: 11 inches
  • Size options: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
  • Firmness rating: 6.5 out of 10

This mattress is made entirely of memory foam and is topped with a cooling cover. It’s designed to minimize motion transfer and can be used with any type of bed frame.

Customers say this mattress is soft and comfortable enough to improve their sleep after one night. They also love that it’s relatively lightweight and suits all types of sleeping positions.

Buy the Nectar Memory Foam Mattress online.

Nectar Lush Mattress

Nectar Lush Mattress
  • Price range: $$$–$$$$$
  • Height: 12 inches
  • Size options: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
  • Firmness rating: 6 out of 10

An inch thicker than the regular memory foam mattress, the Lush Mattress offers a slightly softer feel, according to reviews. It may be good for side sleepers.

Customers say this mattress is like sleeping on a cloud, and they don’t get overheated at night.

Buy the Nectar Lush Mattress online.

Casper mattresses

Casper Original Mattress

Casper Original Mattress
  • Price range: $–$$$
  • Height: 11 inches
  • Size options: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king

This mattress is available either as an all-foam or hybrid version. With three support zones, it’s intended to promote good spinal alignment.

It’s Casper’s least expensive mattress, making it a good budget-friendly pick.

Currently, there isn’t a firmness rating on Casper’s website for this mattress. However, customers say they fell asleep quickly on the Casper Original, and that it’s soft enough for a great night’s sleep.

Buy the Casper Original Mattress online.

Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress

  • Price range: $$–$$$$$
  • Height: 12 inches
  • Size options: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king

Made with coils and breathable foam, this mattress includes seven zones with increased support, which are meant to promote better spinal alignment.

It’s a good choice for those who want more support, or who don’t like the feel of an all-foam mattress.

Currently, there isn’t a firmness rating on Casper’s website for this mattress. However, customers say it offers great spinal support and keeps them cool at night.

Buy the Casper Nova Hybrid Mattress online.

Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress

  • Price range: $$$–$$$$$
  • Height: 13 inches
  • Size options: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king

A hybrid of coils and foam, this mattress includes gel pods placed at waist and lower back heights for extra support. The cover is made with more than 121 recycled bottles.

Currently, there isn’t a firmness rating on Casper’s website for this mattress. But customers highlight that it’s perfect for side sleepers who need extra support.

Buy the Casper Wave Hybrid Mattress online.

A mattress is a pretty big purchase. Here’s what you’ll want to consider before you zero in on your final choice.

Sleeping style and firmness

The best way to start narrowing down your options is to reflect on your sleeping style. Are you a side sleeper, back sleeper, or stomach sleeper?

If you sleep on your side, you may want to go with a softer mattress so you don’t experience hip or shoulder pain. But if you sleep on your back or stomach, a firmer mattress will keep you from sinking into the bed.

Pain relief

It’s also helpful to think about whether you typically experience body aches and pains at night.

Mattress comfort is pretty subjective. Sometimes pain can just be a sign that you need to replace your mattress.

But if you have persistent back pain, research suggests that a medium-firm mattress is optimal for comfort and spinal alignment.

Having a mattress that fully supports your body will also help contribute to a full night’s sleep.

A report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) suggests that a lack of sleep can affect your physical well-being and intensify chronic diseases.

Materials and type

Casper offers all-foam and hybrid mattresses, while Nectar offers all-foam mattresses.

If you like a softer bed that feels like it’s hugging you, or if you want better motion isolation, you may want to consider a foam mattress.

If you’re looking for extra support or dislike the “sinking in” feeling of foam, a hybrid mattress may work best for you.

Company policies

You’ll want to consider delivery service, company warranties, and trial periods before you make your purchase.

It’s also a good idea to take a look at customer reviews to see what people who’ve slept on the mattress have to say about it.

Nectar

Nectar mattresses are delivered rolled up in a box.

Nectar also offers white-glove delivery service. This means they’ll deliver and set up your new mattress for you. They’ll also remove your old mattress at your request.

Casper

Casper mattresses are delivered rolled up in a box.

Casper doesn’t offer white-glove delivery service for most products. However, if you buy a Wave Hybrid king or California king, you can pay extra to have someone deliver and set it up for you. They’ll also haul away your old mattress if you opt into this service.

Nectar

All Nectar mattresses come with a 365-night home trial, a “forever” warranty, and free shipping and returns.

If you decide you want to return your Nectar mattress, you’ll contact the customer service and they’ll help you find a local donation center. Once you donate the mattress, Nectar will send you a full refund.

The warranty will repair defects found within the first 10 years. After that, Nectar will replace your mattress if defects are found.

Casper

All Casper mattresses come with a 100-night home trial, a 10-year limited warranty, and free shipping and returns.

If you want to return your Casper mattress within the 100-night trial window, the company will send a courier to collect your mattress. You don’t have to try to stuff it back in the box. After that, you’ll get a refund.

Nectar

Nectar mattresses are all CertiPUR-US certified. This means each mattress has foam made of materials that are good for the ozone and environment (no mercury, lead, heavy metals, formaldehyde, and more).

The brand also uses organic wool, natural latex, and organic cotton.

Casper

Casper mattresses are also CertiPUR-US certified.

Nectar

Nectar has a Better Business Bureau (BBB) profile, but it’s not rated.

The company recently settled Federal Trade Commission (FTC) charges in 2018. Nectar agreed to stop making false claims that its mattresses were made in the United States. They’re actually made in China.

Nectar hasn’t had any major product recalls.

Casper

Casper is BBB accredited with an A+ rating.

Casper has been subject to a couple lawsuits. A 2017 class-action lawsuit alleged that Casper tracked visitors on Casper.com to gain personal information like addresses. However, the case was dismissed in 2018.

In 2020, another class-action was filed based on the company not declaring profit-related issues to investors.

It doesn’t appear that Casper mattresses have been recalled due to safety concerns.

Nectar

Across the board, Nectar’s customer reviews on its website say the mattress is comfortable, soft, and cradles the body.

However, on Trustpilot, reviews are mixed. Nectar have two pages: one for the United Kingdom and one for the United States.

On the U.K. page, customers mostly share positive experiences, with a few poor reviews citing bad customer service.

On the U.S. page, customers mostly say they’ve had terrible customer service with the lack of a response being the overwhelming verdict.

Casper

On Casper’s website, the reviews are all positive. Customers say the delivery was simple and that the mattress provides the best sleep they’ve had.

Trustpilot also has a majority of excellent reviews. Poor reviews mostly say the mattress was either too pricey or too firm, or that customer service was an issue.

Casper and Nectar are two established bed-in-a-box brands. Both have a small range of mattresses: all foam for Nectar, and foam or hybrid for Casper.

To make your choice, consider your comfort and preferences, and be sure to take advantage of the free in-home trial.

No matter the brand and type of mattress you choose, you won’t go wrong with a mattress that’s designed for your comfort and tested by you directly.


Robin Mosley is a Chicago-based writer. Her work has appeared in publications including Food and Wine and The Kitchn. Her work deals with food, gaming, or business connected to intersectional identities. You can keep up with her on Twitter or on her website.