We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.
Boll & Branch and Brooklinen are among the most popular luxury sheet companies for good reason.
Both were founded on the ideas of purity, safety, and quality.
If you’re on the hunt for swoon-worthy percale cotton sheets, both brands are bound to come up in your search. But what distinguishes one from the other?
Here’s how Boll & Branch and Brooklinen sheets compare.
Although both brands sell a variety of sheets, the percale sets are particularly popular. Here’s a side-by-side look at them.
|Boll & Branch||Brooklinen|
|Mattress depth (inches)||17||15|
|Certifications||Fair Trade certified cotton and factory, Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified cotton, OEKO-TEX Standard 100||OEKO-TEX Standard 100|
|Known for||luxury organic sheets with a commitment to sustainable and ethical supply chains||quality and affordability|
The Brooklinen percale sheets start at $109 for a twin set and go up to $179 for a California king set, while the more expensive Boll & Branch’s percale sheets start at $160 for a twin set and go up to $295 for a split California king set.
|Boll & Branch||Brooklinen|
|Split California king||$295|
Boll & Branch Percale Hemmed Sheet Set
- Sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, king with standard cases, California king, and split California king
- Includes: one flat sheet, one fitted sheet, and one pillowcase for twin and twin XL; one flat sheet, one fitted sheet, and two pillowcases for full, queen, king, and California king; one flat sheet, two fitted sheets, and two pillowcases for California split king
- Colors: White, Ivory, Pale Pewter, Pewter, Stone, Shore, Blush, and Pale Eucalyptus
If you’re a fan of 5-star hotel bed linens, you’re in luck. Boll & Branch’s percale weave offers a cool, crisp, and smooth feel with a tailored aesthetic.
These luxurious sheets are a modern classic made with 100% GOTS certified organic cotton and a 360 thread count. The percale weave has a matte finish, and the sheets are described as soft and comfortable.
They’re also generously sized to accommodate mattresses up to 17 in. thick.
One of Boll & Branch’s pillars is their commitment to ethical production, meaning adult workers in India, Portugal, and the United States are paid fair living wages and have safe, respectful work environments.
Because of these standards, Boll & Branch was the first Fair Trade certified manufacturer of linens.
The company’s keen sense of responsibility extends to the environment, too. Boll & Branch commits to using organic cotton, so they begin with a safer, more sustainable raw product that makes a softer, more luxurious finished product.
This is echoed in the several hundred reviews on the Boll & Branch website. Customers love the quality and texture of these sheets, saying they’re exactly as described.
However, one or two negative reviews describe the sheets as stiff and oversized in the corners.
Brooklinen Classic Core Sheet Set
- Sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king
- Includes: one flat sheet, one fitted sheet, and two pillowcases
- Colors: Solid White, Cream, Graphite, Window Pane, Graphite and Steel Oxford Stripe, Deep Navy, and Rose; limited edition colors vary
The Brooklinen percale sheets are made with 100% long-staple cotton for a crisp, yet cozy, coolness that lasts through the night.
These sheets fall into the classic “hotel sheet” category. A Healthline editor who tested them describes them as crisp, lightweight, and breathable.
Brooklinen’s sheets are made with 270 thread count cotton percale weave, certified by OEKO-TEX to be free of harmful chemicals, and cut to fit mattresses up to 15 in. in depth.
They’re also smartly equipped with “long side” and “short side” labels for convenience. Brooklinen’s percale pillowcases use envelope closures for a tidy, closed aesthetic.
Reviewers are particularly taken with the smoothness, softness, and overall quality of the sheets. Close to 13,000 reviews on the Brooklinen website rank them 4.6 out of 5 stars.
However, some customers complain that the fitted sheet isn’t deep enough for their mattress, while others find the sheets too thin for their liking.
Choosing between Boll & Branch and Brooklinen percale sheets will likely boil down to personal preference.
When testing both sheets, we found the Boll & Branch to be soft, yet still structured and the Brooklinen to be crisper and more breathable.
If you’re sticking to a budget, Brooklinen’s sheets may be the way to go.
If you make a point of supporting companies that are committed to ethical and sustainable manufacturing processes, Boll & Branch is your best bet. Boll & Branch sheets are also available in more sizes and will fit a mattress 2 in. deeper than Brooklinen’s sheets.
Keep in mind that a percale weave is designed to be cool, smooth, and crisp.
Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch offers free shipping and returns with a 30-night, risk-free trial.
The company won’t accept returns after 30 days, and they don’t offer exchanges at this time.
All last call products are final sale and cannot be returned.
Brooklinen’s sheets ship free.
The company strives to ensure their customers get the best deals, so they’ll make pricing adjustments if you placed an order up to 14 days before an active promotion begins. The same is true if you forgot to add a promo code at checkout.
In both cases, you can contact the company directly for help.
Brooklinen makes it easy to return or exchange sheets if they aren’t a good fit. Customers have 365 days to make a return or exchange, and Brooklinen will even pay for return shipping if you’re in the United States.
As a core product, the percale sheets have an additional 1-year extended warranty after the initial 365-day term.
If you’re buying Brooklinen sheets from a third-party retailer, you’ll need to process any returns or exchanges through that site. You’re subject to their respective policies.
Keep in mind that any final sale or last call items can’t be returned. Still, if you make a purchase from the section and find it’s defective, Brooklinen will work with you to find a resolution.
Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch sheets can be purchased through the company website and in their retail stores around the country. Select sets are also available at Nordstrom.
Sales are limited at Boll & Branch, but they do offer discounted pricing on last call items. Note that all sales on last call sheets are final.
The best deals and options for Brooklinen’s sheets can be found on the company website and in their Williamsburg store in Brooklyn. That’s where you’ll find new customer discounts and various sales.
You can also find Brooklinen sheets for sale on third-party sites like Zola Home.
Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch sheets should be machine washed with like colors on a gentle cycle with cold water. They can go in a dryer on low heat.
Boll & Branch recommends shaking the linens between washing and drying to minimize wrinkles.
Because the Boll & Branch production process is free of chemical sizing agents, there may be mild shrinking after the first wash. To account for this, Boll & Branch sheets are slightly oversized.
The company advises that, if your sheets fit a little loosely in the beginning, they should fit just right after a few washes.
To preserve the fibers, colors, and elasticity of your sheets, Brooklinen recommends washing them on a cool or warm cycle before line drying. This will also help prevent significant wrinkling.
Brooklinen doesn’t pre-shrink their linens, so it’s best to avoid hot water and hot cycles in the dryer.
If you want to toss your sheets in the dryer anyway, use a low heat and low tumble cycle. To avoid wrinkles, Brooklinen recommends taking them out 5 minutes before the end of the cycle and laying them flat to finish drying.
Boll & Branch and Brooklinen both offer popular percale sheet sets that are similar in durability and care.
With Boll & Branch, there are a few more sizing options, and the sheets are designed to accommodate deeper mattresses.
Boll & Branch is deeply invested in ethical and sustainable production, but you’ll also spend more than you would at Brooklinen.
Reviews for the percale sheets from both brands are overwhelmingly positive. So, really, you can’t go wrong with either choice.
Jessica Timmons has been working as a freelance writer since 2007, covering everything from pregnancy and parenting to cannabis, chiropractic, stand-up paddling, fitness, martial arts, home decor, and much more. Her work has appeared in mindbodygreen, Pregnancy & Newborn, Modern Parents Messy Kids, and Coffee + Crumbs. See what she’s up to now at jessicatimmons.com.