HEALTH NEWS

Women’s Health Issues: Where the 2016 Presidential Candidates Stand

Written by Jamie Reno on March 14, 2016

womens health issues

Women’s health has taken center stage in the 2016 presidential election.

And like actors auditioning for a coveted lead role in a Broadway play, the cast of characters in this unfolding political drama — former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, New York businessman Donald Trump, Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, Ohio Gov. John Kasich, and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio — are each trying to position themselves as “Best Advocate” for women’s health.

The field is full of vast and volatile issues that mean different things to different people.

Women’s health encompasses everything from abortion, Planned Parenthood and birth control, to family leave and sexual assault.

And some of the candidates have navigated their way through this political minefield rather awkwardly.

trump

For example, Trump, the Republican frontrunner has been sharply criticized for the crude way he’s described various women such as former Republican presidential candidate Carly Fiorina and Fox News host Megyn Kelly.

Yet, he says, he’s the best candidate for female voters.

“I’m going to be really good for women. I’m going to be good for women’s health issues,” Trump said during his Super Tuesday victory speech two weeks ago.

Clinton, who leads the Democratic race, likes to point out that she’s been an advocate for women’s health since she was a young activist, as an attorney, as first lady of Arkansas, as first lady in the White House, as a senator, and then as secretary of state.

clinton

But the political moderate, who recently has taken a few left turns in the wake of rival Sanders’ surprising success in the Democratic primaries, has expressed skepticism in the past about the likelihood of certain women’s health issues becoming law.

At a CNN town hall meeting in June 2014, Clinton said that while she supported the idea of paid family leave, she wasn’t sure it was “politically feasible” to offer it to America’s workers.

“I think, eventually, it should be [adopted],” Clinton said at the time. “I don’t think, politically, we could get it now.”

So where do each of the presidential candidates really stand on these important women’s health issues?

Healthline takes a close look.

where candidates stand

Abortion

People on both sides of the emotional abortion debate are calling this election the most important one for abortion policy in decades.

If you believe abortion should remain legal and accessible, you’ll probably like the Democrats’ (Clinton and Sanders) positions on this issue.

If you’re against abortion and believe it should be banned or at least restricted, you’ll probably like the Republicans’ (Trump, Cruz, Kasich, and Rubio) positions.

Trump described himself as pro-choice for years. On NBC’s Meet the Press in 1999 he said he was “very pro-choice,” and reiterated that position in his 2000 book “The America We Deserve.”

But now he describes himself as “pro-life.”

Cruz is adamantly anti-abortion and a staunch supporter of a Texas law that led to the closure of dozens of abortion clinics.

rubio

Image source: Wikimedia

Rubio, who supports a ban on abortion even in the case of rape, recently told Sean Hannity in a radio interview that “the science is settled. It’s not even a consensus. It’s a unanimity that human life begins at conception.”

As Ohio governor, Kasich helped provide the first-ever state funding for rape crisis centers, but on the issue of abortion he is a hardliner.

Kasich has enacted multiple restrictions on women’s health in Ohio and closed nearly half of the abortion providers in the state.

The Supreme Court is currently reviewing Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, which addresses a law in Texas that opponents say unconstitutionally restricts abortion access in that state.

Since the Texas law was enacted, dozens of abortion clinics in Texas have reportedly closed, leaving just 17 in the large state.

A new report from the Texas Policy Evaluation Project concluded that since the abortion clinics were closed, nearly 2 percent of 18- to 49-year-old women in Texas — that’s anywhere from 100,000 to 240,000 women — have tried to self-induce an abortion.

The report also showed that wait times for abortion appointments increased to as long as 23 days at clinics in Austin and Ft. Worth due to clinic closures.

The court is expected to render its decision in June on this case.

Planned Parenthood

Among the most contentious issues on the campaign trail is the debate over funding of Planned Parenthood, which has more than 650 health centers nationwide.

Last month, a grand jury looked into the widely publicized videos of Planned Parenthood workers secretly recorded by the Center for Medical Progress, an anti-abortion group.

The group insisted the videos show Planned Parenthood officials discussing the sale of fetal tissue. Planned Parenthood says it does not sell fetal tissue.

The grand jury ultimately cleared Planned Parenthood of any wrongdoing in the case and instead indicted the filmmakers on a felony charge of tampering with a governmental record.

While both of the Democratic candidates support the continued federal funding of Planned Parenthood, the four Republicans in the race are against funding the organization, although Trump has waffled.

In response recently to a question about his flip on Planned Parenthood, Trump said, “Planned Parenthood has done very good work for some — for many, many — for millions of women. But we’re not gonna allow it, we’re not gonna fund so long as you have the abortion going on at Planned Parenthood.”

Trump made this declaration despite the fact that the Hyde Amendment in 1976 prohibited federal dollars from being used for abortion. That was amended in 1993 by President Bill Clinton to make exceptions in cases of rape and incest.

Regardless, it appears Trump would only support funding Planned Parenthood if the organization ceased providing abortion services, which is unlikely.

Meanwhile, the rest of the Republican candidates are definitive in their opposition to any funding for the organization.

Last year, Cruz reportedly sent an email urging pastors to “confront this evil in our nation by praying and preaching with an unbridled passion until funding for Planned Parenthood ends.”

In an op-ed piece for USA Today last August, Cruz made clear his opposition to the organization.

“Despite what Planned Parenthood contends, abortion procedures, not women’s health, are its lifeblood. Hundreds of thousands of annual abortions generate nearly 40 percent of Planned Parenthood’s clinic revenues. Simply put, Planned Parenthood is the nation’s largest abortion profiteer,” he said.

Kasich, who’s cast himself as the moderate among the remaining Republicans in the race, signed legislation as governor of Ohio in 2013 that defunded the organization in his state.

kasich

Image source: Wikimedia

Not surprisingly, Planned Parenthood is openly critical of all four Republican candidates.

Dawn Laguens, executive vice president of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, told Healthline the GOP candidates “all have the same plan for women's health: banning abortion, blocking over a million people from basic health care at Planned Parenthood, and slashing insurance coverage of birth control.”

Laguens said the GOP candidates’ efforts to defund Planned Parenthood would block access for millions of women to cancer screenings, sexually transmitted disease testing, and other preventative services.

“This would have devastating consequences for women,” she said.

Recently, Planned Parenthood initiated an advertising campaign in support of Clinton. In response, Sanders referred to the endorsement as "the establishment" supporting its own.

Clinton responded to his accusation.

“I don’t understand what that means,” she said. “He’s been in Congress a lot longer than I have.”

After the exchange, Sanders began regularly expressing his support for Planned Parenthood on the campaign trail.

Birth Control

While Clinton and Sanders both support the idea of full access to birth control, the Republican candidates have been hostile toward virtually any form of contraception.

Each of the GOP candidates would slash insurance coverage of birth control under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), also known as Obamacare.

cruz

Image source: Wikimedia

Cruz, who sponsored a bill to ban a Washington D.C. law that protects women from being fired if they take birth control, has frequently said that the birth control coverage rule included in the ACA forces employers to cover abortion-inducing pills.

Trump has said he would cut insurance coverage of birth control. If he were successful, women would pay an estimated $1.4 billion more a year to cover their birth control, according to the Planned Parenthood Action Fund.

Rubio was one of 22 Senators who in 2012 introduced the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which would repeal the contraceptives program in the ACA. It provides 18 types of birth control with “no out-of-pocket costs.”

Family Leave

There is still no federal mandate for businesses to provide paid family leave. Nearly 90 percent of Americans in the work force reportedly don’t have viable family leave options at work.

The United States is one of a handful of nations that doesn’t offer federal paid family leave plan.

But the issue is getting more attention this year.

While Clinton did state two years ago that family leave might not be “politically feasible,” during a debate last October she’s changed her stance on the issue.

“It’s about time we had paid family leave for American families and join the rest of the world,” she said.

At the same debate, Sanders, who’s been supportive of family leave and other women’s health issues throughout his life, made it clear he thinks the federal government has a responsibility to provide such a program.

“When you look around the world ... you see every other major country saying to moms that, when you have a baby, we're not going to separate you from your newborn baby, because ... we are going to have medical and family paid leave, like every other country on Earth,” he said

sanders

While Clinton and Sanders now both support 12 weeks of paid leave, the Republican candidates haven’t evolved much on the issue since former House Speaker John Boehner called the Family and Medical Leave Act “another example of yuppie empowerment” in 1993.

When asked about family leave while campaigning last summer at the Iowa State Fair, Cruz said he didn’t support a national plan.

“I think maternity leave and paternity leave are wonderful things. I support them personally. But I don’t think the federal government should be in the business of mandating them,” he said.

Kasich has said he opposes the federal mandate but supports some alternatives like allowing new mothers to work online from home.

Rubio is the only GOP candidate who supports any sort of federal family leave initiative.

Last fall he introduced a plan that would provide a 25 percent non-refundable tax credit for businesses that voluntarily offer at least four weeks of paid family leave, limited to 12 weeks of leave and $4,000 per employee each year.

“Expanding access to paid family leave is part of Marco’s pro-family, pro-growth agenda,” the plan states. “The status quo too often forces workers — especially new mothers — to quit their job permanently when they need time away from it, making it harder to return to work one day.”

But critics of the plan, including Bryce Covert, the economic policy editor for the liberal group ThinkProgress, say that a tax credit may not be enough to encourage all employers to offer family leave, which would leave the plan helping only employees that are well off.

When asked by Fox News about his thoughts on paid family leave, Trump offered few specifics.

“It’s something that’s being discussed; I think we have to keep our country very competitive, so you have to be careful of it. But certainly there are a lot of people discussing it.”

A number of recent studies show family leave actually being a positive for the economy.

A study from Rutgers University concluded that new mothers who take paid leave are more likely to be working again nine to 12 months after childbirth, than mothers who don’t take any leave.

A study from the U.S. Census Bureau concluded that new mothers who take paid are more likely to return to the same employer than those who take unpaid leave or no leave.

Anita Raj, PhD, director of University of California San Diego’s Center on Gender Equity and Health and professor in the university’s Division of Global Public Health, said paid family leave is among the most significant women’s health issues on the table in this election.

“Leaving employment to care for a child and being forced to feel constrained or vulnerable to losing your job because you are needed is deeply unfair and can cause great stress” Raj told Healthline. “And this disproportionately affects women.”

Sexual Assault

There are a few issues involving women’s health that haven’t received a lot of attention this campaign season.

Raj noted one conspicuously missing from the 2016 campaign trail is sexual assault and, more specifically, the epidemic of college campus rape.

“Given all the recent attention paid to the issue, from Joe Biden’s efforts to the recent CNN and Oscar-nominated documentary, and the Oscar-nominated song, sung by Lady Gaga, it’s striking that it is not a big issue in this election,” Raj said.

Sanders’ plan to make college free, Raj observed, resonates favorably with young voters.

“College is in people’s consciousness, and sexual assault on college campuses is the most important women’s health issue that we have not legislatively tackled in this country,” she said. “We need better prevention efforts.”

Raj said many survivors of sexual assault are dissatisfied with services and are often frustrated with the criminal justice system.

“These acts compromise their education,” Raj said. “I should not be afraid to send my daughter to college, but I am.”

CMS Id: 100284