- Researchers say people on a vegan diet have a high risk of broken bones, particularly hip fractures.
- They said a lower body mass index as well as a lack of calcium and protein can be factors.
- Experts say vegans can still maintain strong bones by taking vitamins D and B12 as well as seeking out meat-free foods that contain a healthy amount of protein.
People who don’t eat meat, in particular vegans, may be at an increased risk of bone fractures.
Researchers at Oxford University in England report that vegans have a 43 percent higher risk of having fractures anywhere in the body, as well as higher risks of fractures in certain areas like the hip.
“We found that vegans had a higher risk of total fractures, which resulted in close to 20 more cases per 1,000 people over a 10-year period compared to people who ate meat. The biggest differences were for hip fractures, where the risk in vegans was 2.3 times higher than in people who ate meat, equivalent to 15 more cases per 1,000 people over 10 years,” Tammy Tong, PhD, BSc, the lead author of the study and a nutritional epidemiologist at the Nuffield Department of Population Health at the University of Oxford, said in a
Of the participants, nearly 30,000 were meat eaters, about 8,000 didn’t eat meat but did eat fish, about 15,000 were vegetarian, and nearly 2,000 were vegans at the beginning of the study.
Participants were tracked for an average of 18 years until 2016. During that time, 3,941 fractures occurred. The highest number of fractures were in the hip, followed by the wrist, arm, ankle, and leg.
The researchers said that vegetarians and people who ate fish but not meat had a higher risk of hip fractures than their counterparts who ate meat. This risk was partially reduced when body mass index (BMI), calcium, and protein intake were taken into account.
“Previous studies have shown that low BMI is associated with a higher risk of hip fractures, and low intakes of calcium and protein have both been linked to poorer bone health. This study showed that vegans, who on average had lower BMI as well as lower intakes of calcium and protein than meat eaters, had higher risks of fractures at several sites,” Tong said.
“Well-balanced and predominantly plant-based diets can result in improved nutrient levels and have been linked to lower risks of diseases, including heart disease and diabetes,” she added. “Individuals should take into account the benefits and risks of their diet, and ensure that they have adequate levels of calcium and protein and also maintain a healthy BMI, that is, neither under nor overweight.”
Lauri Y. Wright, PhD, an assistant professor of nutrition and dietetics at the University of North Florida, said the findings of the research aren’t surprising.
“The study results are consistent with previous studies, so not a surprise. The findings of increased fractures in non-meat eaters was partially explained by protein and calcium intake as well as BMI. However, there continued to be higher risk of fractures in vegans when those factors were controlled. This may be related to bioavailability of those key nutrients in bone health,” Wright told Healthline.
“For example, the vegans may have consumed adequate amounts of calcium, but many plant-based sources of calcium like spinach are not as bioavailable as dairy,” she added. “Protein quality is another example. Vegans may have consumed an adequate amount of plant proteins, but the amino acid ratio does not support resorption and remodeling as well as the amino acid ratio in animal proteins.”
All the experts who spoke with Healthline said it’s possible to be vegan and still have healthy bones.
“I have many patients that are vegan and when done correctly, studies do not show drawbacks,” Kristin Kirkpatrick, MS, a registered dietitian and manager of wellness nutrition services at the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute in Ohio, told Healthline.
“The key is doing it right,” she explained. “For example, an individual can easily consume plenty of vegan processed junk food, which would have adverse impact on health. However, when the focus is whole foods and plants, there is little drawback. Protein can be derived from whole soy, beans, and legumes, as well as nuts and seeds. Supplementation of B12 and vitamin D are also recommended for health.”
Dana Hunnes, PhD, is a senior dietitian at the University of California, Los Angeles and has been a vegan since 2001.
She says back then it was a lot harder for vegans to find alternatives to animal products that were fortified with necessary vitamins and minerals.
“There were fewer vegan products and anyone who wanted to be vegan had to mostly eat fruits, vegetables, and non-fortified food items. When I went vegan… there was literally one brand of soy milk and I don’t believe it had extra calcium or vitamin D in it. Today, there are so many products that mimic animal products and/or have vitamins and minerals supplemented into them,” Hunnes told Healthline.
She says picking the right foods is important for vegans to remain healthy.
“Make sure you get a good balance of fresh produce and potentially some fortified products, including soy milk, almond milk, or cashew milk, which are now mostly all fortified with calcium and vitamin D and other important nutrients,” Hunnes said.
She also advises that vegans do weight-bearing exercises, get enough vitamin D and calcium, and eat a sufficient number of calories.
Despite the findings of the Oxford study, Wright says a vegan diet can be beneficial with proper planning.
“I don’t see that there are drawbacks to being a vegan, just challenges. The vegan needs to be strategic about planning out the diet to ensure adequate intake of certain key nutrients such as vitamin B12, iron, calcium, and zinc. We know that there are many health benefits to being a vegan. Vegans typically have a healthier body weight, have lower cholesterol levels, and a lower risk for many cancers, heart disease, and diabetes,” she said.
“A meat-free diet can provide all the nutrients you need. It just takes a little planning. To ensure a nutritionally adequate diet, eat a variety of whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts and include soy,” Wright added.