Hot Yoga

Bikram yoga and other types of “hot” yoga, which are among the newer styles of the ancient stretching and strengthening activity, have drawn scads of devotees in recent years as yoga has grown faster than nearly any other physical activity in the United States.

A true Bikram yoga class — whose instructor must be trained at the Bikram Yoga College of India, based in Los Angeles — moves through a fixed series of traditional poses in a 90-minute session, in a room with an air temperature of 105 degrees and 40 percent humidity. Many studios tinker with the formula in order to offer their own versions of hot yoga.

But not at Yoga Shala in Portland, Oregon. Owner Jody Kurilla happily sends would-be hot yoga students “down the street” to another studio.

Hot Yoga

For the 25-year yoga devotee, “hot yoga” is a contradiction in terms. Classic yoga should be practiced without profuse sweating or an elevated heart rate, she said. And the practice is not about extremes. It’s about listening to your body without distractions.

“The idea is if you’re sweating a lot, the session is too difficult. You can be lightly sweating, but if your [breathing] or your heart rate starts to go up, you’re supposed to take a break. So to put yourself into a hot room, and do that on purpose, it’s not what yoga was designed to do,” she said. “You’re supposed to be cultivating prana, or energy, not dispersing it.”

She says hot yoga practitioners get addicted to the endorphins their bodies produce in response to being pushed further than it wants to go.

To put yourself into a hot room, and do that on purpose, it’s not what yoga was designed to do.
Jody Kurilla, Yoga Shala in Portland, Oregon

“Yoga is not about extremes,” Kurilla said. “As the Dalai Lama said, the highs are very high, the lows are very low, and the middle is very boring. But after time, it becomes much more profound.”

Hot yoga proponents say that by doing their poses in a super-heated room, they gain more flexibility than those who do the same poses at room temperature. The heat forces the heart to beat faster, which advocates say provides a better cardiovascular workout and burns more calories. Sweating profusely, they say, flushes the body of toxins.

They also make the point that yoga comes from India, where the climate is warm.

But critic Kurilla fires back, “They don’t practice outside in the hot weather. They practice in the morning before the sun comes up and in the evening after the sun goes down.”

Yoga in a heated room is a novel, contentious experiment in the 5,000-year history of yoga. There’s a thick bundle of modern scientific studies documenting the potential for conventional yoga to lower stress and blood pressure and improve flexibility and balance. But almost nothing is known about what happens when you move yoga into a super-heated room.

Read More: Yoga Can Ease Multiple Sclerosis Symptoms »

New Study Throws Cold Water on Hot Yoga

The American Council on Exercise (ACE) recently published a study raising concerns about Bikram.

During a 90-minute class, body temperature rose consistently in healthy participants experienced in hot yoga, the study found. The participants’ temperatures topped out at 103 degrees, narrowly missing the 104-degree threshold that doctors consider dangerous.

“For a person who’s unfit or not used to Bikram, there’s some [concern] that they might experience some level of heat intolerance,” said Cedric Bryant, Ph.D., chief science officer at ACE.

ACE recommends that newcomers stick to conventional yoga or try hot yoga at a studio that offers it at lower heat. An earlier ACE study found that hot yoga classes at lower temperatures do not pose a risk. But all hot yoga participants should lie down or leave the room if they feel nauseous, light-headed, or confused in a class.

“You do want to use some common sense if you’re feeling out of sorts,” Bryant said.

Allison Abel Rissel, a North Dakota yoga instructor who, as part of her graduate training in exercise physiology, published research on the health benefits of hot yoga, agreed.

“It is hot in that room, but as long as you’re properly hydrated, I think it’s a manageable heat,” she said.

Groupon’s out there saying you can try hot yoga, and it’s usually somebody that’s never practiced yoga before. They're not hydrated. They're not in shape.
Mindy Caplan, yoga instructor

But, according to Mindy Caplan, a yoga instructor and a health fitness specialist certified through the American College of Sports Medicine, many participants don’t ease in to the higher temperatures.

“Groupon’s out there saying you can try hot yoga, and it’s usually somebody that’s never practiced yoga before and they go in there,” she said. “They’re not well hydrated. They’re not in shape."

Caplan briefly tried Bikram and doesn’t recommend it for students.

Pregnant women and people with diabetes or any sort of cardiovascular problem, including high blood pressure, should avoid hot yoga, according to recommendations from ACE and Canadian health groups.

On their website, the Bikram Yoga College of India says that doing this form of yoga will alleviate high blood pressure. It indicates the practice is safe for pregnant women but advises them to consult their doctors.

The school did not respond to a request for an interview.

Rissel said she’s seen pregnant women in hot yoga classes, but they were acclimated because “they’d been doing it for years.”

Culture Shock

Part of what sets Bikram apart even from other forms of hot yoga is the style of instruction, critics say. While most yoga classes, including many hot ones, encourage students to take things at their own pace, Bikram instructors often don’t.

Critics say teachers trained at the Bikram Yoga College follow a script, and the script calls for them to encourage students to stretch further into their poses and not to leave the room if they feel overwhelmed by the heat. Instructors sometimes follow students out of the room to persuade them to come back in.

Some liken the instructional style to boot camp.

But Rissel defended the instructors’ efforts to keep students in the yoga studio. The rationale is “mindfulness,” she said, or encouraging students to simply accept their feelings rather than escape them. Mindfulness can be effective at helping people handle psychological stresses.

But the persistent urgings of Bikram instructors make it difficult for some people to listen to their own bodies, Caplan said.

It’s hard to recognize your limits, she said, “when you’re pretty much being told, ‘This is how you do it: Go deeper, go deeper!’”

Related News: How Yoga Improves Overall Athletic Performance »

You Won’t Melt Your Waistline

Still, Bikram yoga isn’t as dangerous as, say, an early-season football practice in Texas, ACE’s Bryant said.

“The fact of the matter is that there are large numbers of participants in Bikram, and it isn’t like the vast majority of those people are having any issues,” Bryant said.

Hot yoga’s saving grace, he said, is that it’s not very vigorous. The body can handle gentle activity at a high temperature, but vigorous activity, like football, is too much.

I wouldn’t advocate it as a practice to try to promote greater calorie burn for weight loss. I think most practitioners would be sorely disappointed if they went to it for that.
Cedric Bryant, Ph.D., American Council on Exercise

Yet, the caloric tally of hot yoga is one of its major selling points. It’s one reason why hot yoga is Rissel’s primary form of exercise, she said.

This selling point appears to be unfounded. According to a series of studies, including one funded by the Bikram Yoga College, hot yoga burns only about 500 calories in a 90-minute class — half of what some proponents and fitness apps promise.

“I wouldn’t advocate it as a practice to try to promote greater calorie burn for weight loss,” Bryant said. “I think most practitioners would be sorely disappointed if they went to it for that.”

Stretching Boundaries

Other students brave the smell of hot yoga’s sweat-soaked rooms because they feel more flexible in the heat.

But the jury is still out on whether this flexibility is a good thing or an invitation to injury.

Critics like Caplan and Kurilla say that, with instructors urging students to push further, the environment is ripe for injury. Caplan injured herself doing Bikram yoga.

“People don’t listen to their bodies, and they injure themselves because they overstretch. I practiced [Bikram yoga] for probably three months until I injured myself — and I don’t often do that, and I know that it was because I overstretched,” she said.

Hot yoga devotee Rissel agreed the heat increases flexibility. But she sees overstretching as simply a question of overdoing it.

Bikram class

“If you’re going to overstretch in a Bikram class, you’re going to overstretch in any class,” she said.

Injuries occur in all forms of yoga, but they’re usually mild. Still, it seems that if there were a rash of injuries at hot yoga studios, the word would get out, as Bryant says.

In the final tally, there is an additional risk from the heat in super-hot yoga, and there is no evidence of benefits in hot yoga that don’t exist in conventional yoga, according to Karen Sherman, Ph.D., MPH, a researcher on alternative approaches to health at Group Health Research Institute.

“I do not recommend that people seeking yoga for health use hot yoga,” Sherman said.

Bryant said ACE’s findings are in line with Sherman’s analysis, but ACE stopped short of advising healthy people to avoid hot yoga.

Why?

“There are just some people who like exercising in that heated environment,” he said.

Even Kurilla would agree with that.

“If people get out there and they’re moving and they feel better, that’s great. If they get out there and they damage themselves, then that’s a problem,” she said. “People come to yoga for whatever reason they come to the practice, and they either find it and they stay with it or they’re on to the next thing.”

Read More: Yoga for Stress Relief and Mental Health »