Type 2 Diabetes

It's a Type 2 Life
It's a Type 2 Life

San Francisco Bay Area resident Patrick Totty writes about his experiences living with type 2 diabetes

See all posts »

Seducing Hope

TEXT SIZE: A A A

My wife and I keep a list on our refrigerator of the greatest things people have invented—everything from zippers and manmade fire to insulin and smartphones. Trying to come up with things to add to it is one of our favorite pastimes.

We both agree that the Internet, and search engines that access it, are among humankind’s best achievements. But with such wonderfulness comes a caution: While using them gives us access to gobs of information at the click of a mouse or the jab of a finger, a lot of what we run across is bogus. Just today I ran across a website selling a product that promises to reverse type 2 diabetes in 30 days.

Hogwash.

The first “tell” was that except for this website there has been absolutely no news elsewhere about a breakthrough diabetes reversal product. If the claim were legitimate, every news organization on earth would have been shouting out about it.

The second tell was that there was a money-back guarantee. There is no such thing as a cure—or even a powerful new drug or therapy—whose maker promises you your money back if the cure somehow fails to. . . cure.

Are there any BS detectors type 2s can use to sort news about real advances in diabetes therapies from the huckster come ons? I use a few rules of thumb :

  • Words like “cure,” “breakthrough,” “dramatic,”  “reverses diabetes,” “30-day guarantee” get my antennae up. Scientists who produce astounding results always couch their announcements in low-key language. They’re smart enough to know that outside actors like the American Diabetes Association, Reuters, or the Associated Press will be the ones to tout a real breakthrough with the appropriate power adjectives and dramatic headlines.

 

  • Website ads that show a doctor in a white coat, surrounded by large boldface type, set off my alarms. The white coat is a classic appeal to authority, and the doctor sitting or standing alone is intended to make us think of the inspired lone genius who has slaved away for years in his lab before bringing his gift to the world. That’s not how modern science works, especially with diabetes, which is a far more complex disease than we imagined even 20 years ago.

 

  • Endorsements like, “I tried X and within 15 days my fasting blood glucose dropped from 177 to 89.—Mike T., Sarasota, Fla.” or “I’ve used X for six months now, and have been able to stop using both of my diabetes medications.—Sylvia M., Boise, Ida.” The problem is that there is no Mike T. or Sylvia M. They are imaginary people who live in the copywriter’s head.

 

  • I even take product announcements from reliable manufacturers with a grain of salt. Many new features on standard diabetic paraphernalia are more incremental than ground-breaking. I understand any manufacturer’s desire to tout a feature that cost a lot to bring to market and that it is hoping will secure its niche, so I know there’s absolutely no attempt to defraud here. But I also remember it is human nature to sell the sizzle along with the steak.

I live in perpetual hope for some spectacular breakthrough that leads to a cure for type 2 diabetes. But even something as wonderful as hope needs be bounded and tempered. When  copywriters start playing at seducing my hopefulness, I mentally tell them to take a hike.

  • 1

Tags: Controversies , Communication , Drugs

Was this article helpful? Yes No

Recommended for You

  • Do Sulfonylureas Add to Cardiovascular Risks?

    By: Patrick Totty
    Nov 13, 2012

    One of the challenges to having type 2 is trying to stay abreast of new research about the disease. That’s why routinely checking out sites like Healthline on the Internet can be a big help when it comes to talking to your doctor or endocrinolo...

    Read more »

  • Tomorrow Belongs to Us

    By: Patrick Totty
    Nov 08, 2012

    Every one of us who has diabetes, and the people who love us, hope for the day when science finds a way to cure our disease. Not just kick it into remission, but cure. In the meantime, until that great day, it’s good to remember just how ...

    Read more »

  • Small A1c Drop, Big Life Expectancy Gain

    By: Patrick Totty
    Nov 01, 2012

    While controversy swirls around what A1c percentage is ideal for type 2s, no one denies that lower is better. Currently, the recommended A1c target is 6.5%, equivalent to a daily average of140 mg/dL. For older people who’ve been diagnosed for...

    Read more »

  • Words Not Spoken, Facts Not Presented

    By: Patrick Totty
    Oct 24, 2012

    When it comes to dealing with diabetes, never forget that some of the information we get doesn’t always fully disclose the facts. If that sounds paranoid, I don’t mean to come off that way. But as a former newspaperman, I know how easy it is ...

    Read more »

Advertisement

About the Author

Bay Area resident Patrick Totty was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes in July, 2003.

Recent Blog Posts

Advertisement
Advertisement