Type 2 Diabetes

It's a Type 2 Life
It's a Type 2 Life

San Francisco Bay Area resident Patrick Totty writes about his experiences living with type 2 diabetes

See all posts »

Words Not Spoken, Facts Not Presented

TEXT SIZE: A A A

When it comes to dealing with diabetes, never forget that some of the information we get doesn’t always fully disclose the facts.

If that sounds paranoid, I don’t mean to come off that way. But as a former newspaperman, I know how easy it is to slant a story without ever introducing your own opinion into it. One way is simply to not mention pertinent facts that might cast doubt on what some people call the “narrative”—the interpretation of reality you’re trying to push.

Case in point: An article in the New York Times tells about an experiment using exercise and diet to lower the odds of developing cardiovascular disease among type 2 diabetes patients. The story says that researchers cut short what they thought would be a 13-year study by two years when it became apparent that the approach they were taking had a negligible effect on lowering type 2s’ cardiovascular risks.

Instead, it appeared that medications had a much more decisive effect on lowering risks than diet and exercise than anticipated.

While the researchers expressed some dismay at findings they obviously weren’t expecting, they left out one fact that might have hinted to readers a possible flaw in the study: They neglected to describe the diet they were experimenting with.  

Until you know—and this article won’t let us—what they were asking their test subjects to eat, you can’t tell what the real story is. Was it that the researchers were troubled that diet and exercise didn’t work, or that a particular diet and exercise didn’t work?

My suspicion is that the diet they put people on was the standard low-fat, fairly high-carb regimen that health experts have been pushing for the last 50 years. If not, I’m certain they would have told us.

My certainty is based on this: We have reached a point where much of the conventional wisdom about fat and carbohydrates is being met by increasing skepticism. The people who’ve been challenging it were at first dismissed as cranks and eccentrics. We were reassured that they were people so far out of the mainstream of proper scientific thinking that whatever they were saying could be easily dismissed.

But the contradictory evidence, compiled by some brilliant minds, keeps piling up. It is high carb intake that increasingly is being seen as the main culprit in cardiovascular problems, not fat intake. High carbs demonstrably lead to high blood glucose levels, and high blood glucose levels create inflammation—a necessary precondition for damaged arteries and blood vessels.

When you add to that the continuing “expert” advice that high carb intake is OK for people with diabetes—the ADA says up to 180 grams per day is fine for some people—it’s no wonder that even a calorie-modified diet that is still low-fat/high-carb just won’t cut it.

As I said, that’s what I suspect is the reason why the researchers here (or perhaps the reporters) are beating around the bush. It’s difficult to challenge accepted old notions about the nature of things.

Ask Galileo or Pasteur. 

  • 1

Tags: Communication , Food , Controversies

Was this article helpful? Yes No

Recommended for You

  • Small A1c Drop, Big Life Expectancy Gain

    By: Patrick Totty
    Nov 01, 2012

    While controversy swirls around what A1c percentage is ideal for type 2s, no one denies that lower is better. Currently, the recommended A1c target is 6.5%, equivalent to a daily average of140 mg/dL. For older people who’ve been diagnosed for...

    Read more »

  • A Rival to Swiss Chocolate?

    By: Patrick Totty
    Oct 30, 2012

    Although many people think that type 1 diabetics are the only people who take insulin injections, an estimated 11 million type 2s in Europe and North America are also on insulin therapy. They deal with many of the same hassles that type 1s do...

    Read more »

  • A Diabetic Doctor's Take on Carb Cravings

    By: Patrick Totty
    Oct 15, 2012

    I’ve mentioned Dr. Richard Bernstein here before. Bernstein is the 78-year-old Long Island-based doctor who for years has been a thorn in the side of the American Diabetes Association. That’s because of his advocacy of a low-carb approach to bo...

    Read more »

  • Priscilla's Grits

    By: Patrick Totty
    Oct 10, 2012

    I mentioned recently that my wife and I were taking a trip through the beautiful red rock country of southern Utah. To get there, we drove along back roads through California and central Nevada. One of our stops in Nevada was the hamlet of ...

    Read more »

Advertisement

About the Author

Bay Area resident Patrick Totty was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes in July, 2003.

Recent Blog Posts

Advertisement
Advertisement