Reader Comments on “Freedom From Smoking”
James Rowan has left a new comment on your post "Chantix side effects":
This medication has promise in helping smokers, however it is still a dangerous substance. There is still a 50/50 chance that patients will experience severe psychotic side effects. That means that patients might be ok or they might want to claw their faces off, literally. I feel that it is appropriate to have more testing/trials with this drug. Good luck to all.
Posted by James Rowan to Freedom from Smoking at Tue Mar 31, 04:24:00 AM 2009
JF COMMENT: IT IS CLEAR THAT FAR LESS THAN 50% OF PATIENTS USING CHANTIX EXPERIENCE “PSYCHOTIC SIDE EFFECT”. THE REPORTS IVE SEEN SUGGEST IT MAY BE CLOSER TO ONE PER THOUSAND (DEPENDING ON ONES DEFINITION) AND THERE IS A DOUBT ABOUT WHETHER THOSE ARE ACTUALLY CAUSED BY CHANTIX AT ALL.
Dingman, MPH has left a new comment on your post "Triple combination therapy for medically ill smoke...":
In Re: smokeless tobacco:
Jonathan because of your presentations and blogs, I have become more discerning in regards to smokeless tobacco and I want to be very careful not to tell lies about it like the tobacco companies have told lies about cigs and nicotine. I want to tell people the truth as it appears that there is going to come a day when smokeless products will be much less harmful than antitobacco persons(like myself) have been saying. So, I was trying to find out what tobacco product Rick Bender was using, for example, was it the skoal and copengagen with more carcinogens and how has that changed now. Please see this link... it lists many chemicals in the smokeless tobacco.. I think snus does not have all this... I recall the TSNAs and your chart on the amount per type, but not these other chemicals and really do not think it is TRUE that there are thousands of chemicals in any of the smokeless... please tell us the TRUTH of 2009... thank you.
Posted by Dingman, MPH to Freedom from Smoking at Fri Apr 17, 06:30:00 AM 2009
JF COMMENT: THERE IS NO DOUBT THAT ALL TOBACCO CONTAINS SOME CARCINOGENS, AND THAT SOME TYPES CONTAIN VERY DIFFERENT AMOUNTS THAN OTHERS. IT ALSO APPEARS THAT THE OVERALL AVERAGE LEVEL OF CERTAIN CARCINOGENS IN SMOKELESS TOBACCO HAS DECREASED OVER TIME. THE EPIDEMIOLOGICAL DATA SUGGEST THAT THE HARMFULNESS (E.G. ORAL CONCER RISK) IS RELATED TO THE CONCENTRATION OF THESE CARCINOGENS IN THE PRODUCT, AND THAT TYPES OF SMOKELESS TOBACCO THAT ARE KNOWN TO BE RELATIVELY LOW IN TOXIN CONCENTRTATIONS ARE THEREFORE LESS LIKELY TO CAUSE SERIOUS HARMS. BUT MOST SMOKELESS TOBACCO IN THE USA CONTAINS NEEDLESSLY HIGH LEVELS OF TOXINS.
Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Chantix and depression on stopping smoking.":
I have been taking Chantix for about a month and a half. Mood has been a whole lot worse. Terrible in fact-depression at its worst. I am going to stop the Chantix for now. I also have been having very very vivid dreams.
Posted by Anonymous to Freedom from Smoking at Sat Apr 25, 04:58:00 AM 2009
JF COMMENT: VERY HARD TO INTERPRET THIS, PARTICULARLY WITH NO INFO ON SMOKING, BUT IN THIS SITUATION ALWAYS BEST TO TELL YOUR DOCTOR.
Nuria has left a new comment on your post "Do menthol smokers inhale more nicotine and toxins...":
Hi Dr.!! In Mexico they sell an e-cigarette named "cigatronik". They sell cartridges with and without nicotine... as far as I know, no one has corroborated that info. Best regards!!
Posted by Nuria to Freedom from Smoking at Thu Apr 30, 07:13:00 PM 2009
JF COMMENT: THEY SOUND SIMILAR TO THE E-CIGS SELLING AROUND THE WORLD…INTERESTING.