Andrea N. Giancoli, MPH, RDFeeding the Kids and You
Advertisement

100% Fad Free Continued

Andrea Giancoli, MPH, RD

Usually my midweek post is Recipe of the Week. But I felt like "A Day in Food Life of Andrea" from Monday was sort of related cuz it was all about food and meals. I hope you got something out of one of my food days and maybe picked up a tip or two.

With that being said, I thought I'd pick-up where I left off last week when we jumped on the 100% Fad Free band wagon in honor of National Nutrition Month®. I'd like to share with you some more tips the American Dietetic Association has provided to help us steer clear of bogus diets, supplements, nutrition products, services, treatments or devices. Again, our teens are particularly vulnerable, I urge you to share this with them.

When you find yourself being tempted to buy a certain product, subscribe to some new diet, or try a new treatment etc., ask yourself the following questions first. If your answer to any of these questions is “Yes,” it likely means the claim is too good to be true and you should be suspicious.

1. Does it use scare tactics, emotional appeals or a money-back guarantee, rather than proven results?
Playing on emotion, misinformation or fear is common among nonscientific pseudo-experts. Watch for terms like “breakthrough” and “miraculous” or claims that certain foods or additives are “poisons.”

2. Does it use non-scientific terms like “revitalize,” “detoxify” or “balance your body with nature”?
Does it claim to increase stamina, stimulate your body’s healing power or boost your energy level? Words ike “detoxify” are not scientific terms. And no product can increase your stamina, strength or immunity.

3. Does it offer “proof” based on personal testimonials rather than sound science?
Nutrition is a science, based on fact, not emotional belief. Be skeptical of case histories and testimonials if they are the only proof a product works.

4. Does it advise supplements as “insurance” for everyone or recommend very large doses of nutrients?
Not everyone needs a supplement; in fact, taking too much may be harmful. Most healthy people can obtain all the nutrients they need from food. For some people, supplementation is warranted, but that is an individual decision that should be made during consultations with your health-care provider.

5. Does it claim it can “treat,” “cure,” or “prevent” all sorts of health problems, from arthritis to cancer to sexual impotence?
No product or regimen can treat all that ails you. Even as a credible treatment strategy – such as for diabetes and some forms of cancer – nutrition therapy is typically a part of your overall health care, not the only factor.

6. Does it make unrealistic claims such as “reverse the aging process,” “cure disease” or “quick, easy approach”?
There are no “magic bullets” when it comes to health. Most health-promoting approaches take some effort. Quackery thrives because people want simple cures and magic ways to change what is imperfect.

7. Does it blame the food supply as the source of health or behavior problems, belittle government regulations or discredit the advice of recognized medical authorities?
Quacks often criticize these sources, as well as claiming the traditional health community is suppressing their work. They call for “freedom of choice” and promote their unproven techniques as viable alternatives to proven methods. The fact is, you will find choices among well-researched methods.

8. Does it claim its “natural” benefits surpass those of “synthetic” or artificial products?
There is nothing magical or automatically safe about “natural.” From the standpoint of science, the chemical structures of natural and synthetic dietary supplements are essentially the same and the body uses them in the same manner (with the exception of vitamin E; “natural” is more potent than the synthetic form). Even substances found in nature can have natural toxins with potent, drug-like effects.

9. Does it mention a “secret formula” or fail to list ingredients or possible side effects on the label?
By law, medications must carry product information on their packaging, including ingredients, use, dosage, warnings, precautions and what to do if reactions occur. Products sold through quackery may not report this information, including potential side effects and dangers.

Don't be fooled!

(Many thanx to the American Dietetic Association for providing this material)

Permalink | Email Post

3 Comments:

  • At Thu Mar 15, 07:33:00 AM 2007, Blogger Christie Lee said…

    Thank you for putting up a day in your eating plan. I often stuggle with eating too much/too little protein or combining meals to have a balance of protein/carbs and fat, I often get overwhelmed trying to plan it out so I resort back to the basics and eat the same stuff.

    Is it true that it is better to get protein from animal source than peanut butter or yogurt?

    A Day for me would be like:
    AM work out; prior to working out would me 6 oz fat free yogurt and coffee with milk

    After work out:
    3 egg whites
    Oatmeal with some sunflower seeds and a little banana and 1 small date.

    Lunch:
    2 Slices whole wheat bread
    3 tbsp hummus
    1 tsbp guacomele
    Apple

    Snack:
    some kind of carb with peanut butter

    Dinner
    Egg whites or Chicken
    Steamed veggies with some kind of dressing and tsp ilive oil
    Salad with yogurt dill sauce

    Snack:
    this is where I stuggle I always want something sweet so I have been trying ot have an orange and some dark choclate.

     
  • At Mon Mar 19, 10:45:00 AM 2007, Anonymous The Sleep Doctor said…

    Great post. I'm linking to your blog in a post I'm about to hit "publish" on -- about sleep-friendly foods.

     
  • At Mon Mar 19, 01:08:00 PM 2007, Blogger Andrea Giancoli, MPH, RD said…

    HI Christie,
    Thanx for sending your food day. Looks like you are getting plenty of protein with your regimen.

    To answer your question, it is not necessary to obtain your protein from animal products. In fact a plant based diet is considered the healthiest way to go. You can easily get enough protein from plant foods if you are eating a good variety. Most plant food are not complete proteins however (with the exceptio of soy) but in combinations they can make a complete protein i.e. beans and rice. You don't necessarily have to eat the combinations together, as long as you are getting them in somewhere over the course of the day.

    What stuck out to me on your diet is a possible shortage of vgetables unless you are eating about two cups for dinner (the hummus counts towards your veggies btw).

    lastly, I am a fan of dessert. But not overdoing it of course. I find when I allow myself that pleasure in a reasonable portion I don't feel deprived and don't overeat. I think it's so important to feel that nothing is forbidden if it's something you really love. Moderation is the key to everything.

    I hope this helps. Keep the comments coming!

     

Post a Comment

<< Home

The Healthline Site, its content, such as text, graphics, images, search results, HealthMaps, Trust Marks, and other material contained on the Healthline Site ("Content"), its services, and any information or material posted on the Healthline Site by third parties are provided for informational purposes only. None of the foregoing is a substitute for professional medical advice, examination, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of a physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on the Healthline Site. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your doctor or 911 immediately. Please read the Terms of Service for more information regarding use of the Healthline Site.